1998-2000 | 2001-2003 | 2004-2005 | 2006-2009 | Current Year Winners | Full List
 | Wilfredo Roman 1989 A. Philip Randolph High School SUNY Binghamton |
 | Antoinette Sims 1990 Bronx High School of Science New York University |
 | Dyon T. Rozier 1991 Martin Luther King Jr. High School Skidmore College |
| Frank Gilmore, Jr. 1992 Alfred E. Smith High School SUNY Purchase, Monroe College |
| Miguel A. David 1993 Samuel Gompers High School Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute |
| Pamela Ware 1994 John F. Kennedy High School Hunter College |
 | Letesha Reese 1995 Jane Addams High School Manhattan College |
 | Christian Davis 1996 Bronx High School of Science Amherst College |
 | Ebony Ross 1997 A. Philip Randolph High School Temple University |
 | Kanika Brooks 1998 A. Philip Randolph High School Columbia University |
 | Lisa Briggins Tate 1999 Herbert H. Lehman Houses Cornell University |
| Xi'an Glynn 2000 Manhattan Center for Science and Mathematics SUNY Potsdam |
 | Irene Rodriguez 2000 Manhattan Center for Science and Mathematics New York University |
 | Ebony Green 2001 Jane Addams High School Marymount College |
| Miguel Rosario 2001 South Bronx High School SUNY Buffalo |
| Fatima Burton 2002 A. Philip Randolph High School John Jay College |
 | Olisa Christian 2003 Evander Childs High School Baruch College |
 | O'Neil Reid 2003 Roosevelt High School City College |
 | Shaquasia Spears 2004 Manhattan Center for Mathematics and Science SUNY Purchase |
 | Joey Diaz 2004 Roosevelt High School Brooklyn College |
 | Tiffany Martin 2005 Frederick Douglass Academy Colby College |
 | Norma David 2005 Grace Dodge Vocational High School College of New Rochelle |
 | Tyreen Sims 2006 Frederick Douglass Academy Gettysburg College |
 | Paul White 2007 South Bronx High School University of Pennsylvania |
 | Calvin Mack 2007 Frederick Douglass Academy Carnegie Mellon University |
 | Jennifer Martinez 2008 DeWitt Clinton High School Carnegie Mellon University |
 | Olufemi Watson 2009 Frederick Douglass Academy Universtiy of Rochester |
 | Javon Cole 2009 Wadleigh Secondary School for the Performing Arts Buffalo State College |
 | Alma Osorio 2010 LaGuardia High School New York University |
 | Jairo Sosa 2010 Bronx Preparatory Charter School School of Visual Arts |
| Jessica Rosario 2010 Mott Haven Village Preparatory HS |
 | Le-Aisha Myers 2010 Frederick Douglass Academy Lehman College |
 | Jacquan Arzu 2011 Validus Prepatory Academy Marist College |
